Hello dear
Welcome To Primo's Pizza - New Windsor
Welcome to Primo's Pizza – New Windsor, a local gem located at 573 Union Ave, where flavor meets tradition. Renowned for its consistently delicious pizza, customers rave about the thin, crispy crust and rich sauce that never disappoints. Beyond pizza, their menu features delightful wraps and a variety of homemade pasta catering options, ensuring everyone finds something to love. The warm, friendly staff and attentive service make every visit special, as noted by regular patrons who return frequently. With glowing reviews highlighting dishes like the veal parmigiana and Caesar salad, Primo's Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza lover in the area.
About
Primo's Pizza - New Windsor
Welcome to Primo's Pizza - New Windsor, a gem located at 573 Union Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553. This local favorite is renowned for its exceptional pizza and hearty Italian dishes, crafted with a passion that is palpable in every bite. Give them a call at +1 845-569-4463 to place an order or inquire about their delightful menu.
What sets Primo's apart is their unwavering commitment to quality. Customers rave about their pizza, noting the thin, crispy crust that is perfectly cooked and never burnt. As Lisa Giammattei highlights, the pizza is "always consistent"—a hallmark of a well-loved eatery. With a rich, flavorful sauce and a perfect balance of toppings, it's no wonder that this spot has become a staple for many locals.
But Pizza isn’t the only star on their menu. The veal dishes, including the adored Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Siciliana at $26.95 and Veal Marsala at $25.95, are crafted using thick, juicy cuts that offer a delightful textural experience, as Hector Hernandez notes. Each dish reflects the traditional Italian recipes that make this cuisine beloved across homes and restaurants alike. Whether you're in the mood for a creamy Baked Ziti Parmigiana or the comforting Lasagna, your taste buds are guaranteed a joyous journey.
From hearty Baked Dinners to delicious Eggplant Entrees, every selection is made with fresh ingredients and a dedication to flavor. The Eggplant Parmigiana and Eggplant Rollatini are especially well-prepared, catering to both vegetarians and aficionados of Italian cooking.
Finally, the friendly and attentive staff create an inviting atmosphere that attracts returning customers, as seen in the glowing testimonials by patrons like Connie Sanchez and Bryan Takeuchi. The occasional wait due to their popularity is a testament to the quality and enjoyment they deliver. Remember, when they say 20 minutes, they mean every minute is dedicated to ensuring your meal is perfect.
In short, whether you're craving a traditional pizza or an exquisite veal entrée, Primo's Pizza - New Windsor promises an unforgettable culinary experience steeped in rich flavors and community spirit. Come hungry—you're in for a delicious treat!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Best veal parmigiana, real thick juicy veal, not pounded. Great pizza. Owner and staff friendly and courteous. Give it a try and you'll be back for more. ”
“ Every time I visit Newburgh we stop for a pizza here nowhere else this is the best ”
“ Best grilled chick3n Cesar salad in town. I have gone to every place in NW and this is the spot for the salad ”
“ Always love the pizza here! Thin, crispy, and has always been consistent for me. Been ordering here for years, especially when I lived close by, but now I only get to come once in a while yet it's remained the best pizza spot in the area for me. ”
“ This is my spot for Pizza. I have had other dishes from here as well and they are all good but, the Pizza is my favorite! It never disappoints. It is always consistent! The crust is perfectly cooked and crispy - not burnt. The crust is not too big and doughy! Sauce - delicious! Staff always friendly and service speed is good. Sometimes there is a little wait because they are busy but, that's not a bad thing. But, I'm talking about- when they say 20 mins they mean the full 20 mins! Never had to wait more than 5 extra mins. Just order ahead if you are in a rush- its worth the wait! ”
“ Looking for a quick slice? This is the spot. Huge slices, good prices and delicious flavor. Give them a try! ”
“ Meatballs are amazing!!! And cheesy garlic bread is so delicious!!! ”
“ I usually just order pizza and wings but decided to look at the menu and see what else they have. Between all the food I got and the tip for the driver I spent 66 on myself but didn’t realize how much food you get. I’ll have another meal for myself tomorrow. The food tastes great and it’s easy to order online or on the phone. Everyone there is really nice too. I love this place and not many places around here do delivery unless you go through another delivery service that charges you crazy fees. ”